TL;DR
The spreadsheet helped make financial recalculations much faster, while accounting software took over many routine posting and adding tasks. U.S. labor data show bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerk employment fell from about 2.25 million in 1988 to 1.53 million in 2025, while accountant and auditor employment grew. The BLS projects further change through 2035, but those projections do not establish how AI will affect individual jobs.
A November 22, 2026, article from Thorsten Meyer AI examines how spreadsheets and accounting software changed bookkeeping, using U.S. employment figures to show a shift in the balance between clerical roles and accountants. The Bureau of Labor Statistics counted about 1.53 million bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks in 2025, down from about 2.25 million in 1988, while accountants and auditors rose from about 963,000 to 1.6 million. The article presents AI as a further source of change, while noting that forecasts through 2035 are projections.
Get business pricing on tech for your team
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
The account begins with Dan Bricklin imagining a spreadsheet while studying a company takeover at Harvard Business School in 1978. He and programmer Bob Frankston developed VisiCalc, whose first complete package shipped for the Apple II on October 19, 1979, according to Bricklin. Its central feature was automatic recalculation: changing an input updated figures that depended on it, reducing the time required to explore different financial assumptions.
In a 1984 account by writer Steven Levy, an accountant said a what-if calculation that had taken 20 hours by hand took 15 minutes with a spreadsheet. That example describes one reported experience, not a measured average for the profession. Spreadsheets also were not the only technology changing the work: the article says accounting software took over much routine posting and addition.
The employment comparison shows different trends across two broad occupational groups. BLS figures cited by the article put bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks at about 2.25 million in 1988 and about 1.53 million in 2025. Accountants and auditors increased from about 963,000 to about 1.6 million over the same period. The article says that in 2025 the U.S. had roughly one clerk for every accountant, after a historical ratio of around two to one.
AI, Spreadsheets, and Bookkeepers How the roles fit together
Spreadsheets sped up recalculation, and accounting software automated routine processing. Employment shifted across finance roles, while AI’s future effects remain uncertain.
Tools changed the work
Calculation became faster and routine transaction tasks increasingly moved to software.
The first complete package shipped for Apple II in 1979, bringing automatic recalculation to personal computers.
Accounting software handled much routine posting and addition.
The article considers AI a further source of change, but its job effects are not established.
Roles moved in different directions
The reported totals show fewer clerks and more accountants and auditors over the period.
- About 2.25 million in 1988
- About 1.53 million in 2025
- Still a substantial workforce
- About 963,000 in 1988
- About 1.6 million in 2025
- Employment grew over the period
What the figures can tell us
Employment trends describe changing totals, but they do not identify a single cause.
Tasks can shift
Automation of repetitive work does not remove the need for financial judgment, review, or advice.
Cause is unclear
Spreadsheets, accounting software, and wider economic changes all overlap in the historical record.
A forecast, not a result
The BLS outlook points to continued divergence through 2035.
| Group | Projected change | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Clerks | −6% | Projected employment decline |
| Accountants | +5% | Projected employment growth |
Fewer Clerks, More Accountants
The employment figures show that automation’s effects can differ across roles within the same field. Work centered on recording and processing transactions contracted over the period cited, while employment among accountants and auditors grew. That pattern does not by itself prove that spreadsheets caused the changes: the figures cover decades in which accounting software and other economic and workplace changes also mattered.
For people who run businesses or work in finance, the distinction matters because automating repetitive calculations does not automatically remove the need for financial judgment, review or advice. The article describes a shift in the mix of work, not the disappearance of bookkeeping. About 1.53 million clerk jobs remained in 2025, according to the figures it cites.
The next question concerns AI. The article reports that BLS projections published in 2026 anticipate a 6% decline in clerk employment and 5% growth for accountants by 2035. Those forecasts suggest further divergence, but they are estimates of future employment, not confirmed outcomes or a count of jobs attributable to AI.
Products Worth Considering

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones Gen 1, Lunar Blue

Logitech MX Mechanical Wireless Illuminated Keyboard, Tactile Quiet, Graphite

Samsung Odyssey G55C 32-Inch QHD Curved Gaming Monitor
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From VisiCalc to Office Software
Computers were involved in bookkeeping before personal spreadsheets reached office desks. According to DATEV’s account, 65 tax advisers founded the cooperative in Nuremberg on February 14, 1966, to process clients’ bookkeeping by computer. Its first data center used four rented IBM mainframes, at a monthly cost of 245,000 Deutschmarks. Such systems required large machines and specialist operation; they did not give every manager an immediate way to change an assumption and recalculate a sheet.
VisiCalc brought that kind of recalculation to a personal computer. Bricklin later said the first complete package shipped in 1979. Lotus 1-2-3 arrived for the IBM PC in 1983 and soon displaced VisiCalc as the leading spreadsheet, according to the article. Levy reported that Americans bought more than one million spreadsheet programs in 1984, worth more than $250 million, and that VisiCalc alone had sold more than 700,000 copies.
The article places this development in a longer history of tools for calculation. It cites the Computer History Museum’s account of a 1946 arithmetic contest in Tokyo between an American soldier using an electric calculator and a Japanese postal worker using a soroban, or abacus. The museum says the abacus won four of five rounds. The episode is background to the history of calculation, rather than evidence about later employment trends.
“A what-if calculation that used to take 20 hours took 15 minutes with a spreadsheet.”
— Steven Levy, describing an accountant’s experience in a 1984 Harper’s account
What the Employment Figures Cannot Show
The figures cited establish changes in occupational totals, but they do not isolate the effect of spreadsheets from accounting software, shifts in business activity, or other changes in the economy. The comparison also spans different sources and years: the article draws on census figures and BLS data, and the occupational categories may not be directly comparable across the entire period.
The BLS estimates for 2035 are projections, not observed outcomes. The article does not provide the underlying forecast tables or a method for measuring how much future change will be caused specifically by AI. It also does not establish how adoption will vary by business size, industry or job duties, or whether workers will move into other roles.
The 20-hour-to-15-minute comparison comes from one accountant’s reported experience in 1984. It shows the potential time savings for that task, but does not quantify the average time saved across bookkeepers or accountants. The article’s evidence supports a history of changing tasks and employment totals, while the scale and distribution of AI’s future effects remain uncertain.
Watch the 2035 Job Outlook
The next milestone in the account is the BLS employment outlook through 2035. As new labor data arrive, they can show whether the projected decline in clerk roles and growth in accountant roles are borne out. The figures alone will not identify the cause of any change, so understanding AI’s contribution will require evidence about how employers adopt the technology and which tasks it takes over.
For now, the article’s historical record points to a gradual shift: spreadsheets sped up recalculation, accounting software automated some transaction processing, and clerical jobs remained numerous even as their total fell. Whether AI extends that pattern, changes it, or creates demand for different finance work is not yet established.
Key Questions
Did spreadsheets eliminate bookkeeping jobs?
The cited data do not show that spreadsheets alone eliminated jobs. They show that U.S. bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerk employment fell from about 2.25 million in 1988 to about 1.53 million in 2025, while accounting software and other changes also affected the work.
When did VisiCalc first ship?
Dan Bricklin said the first complete VisiCalc package shipped for the Apple II on October 19, 1979.
What does the article say about AI and finance jobs?
It reports that BLS projections anticipate a 6% decline in clerk employment and 5% growth for accountants by 2035, and that the agency expects AI to handle routine tasks such as data entry. These are projections, not confirmed job outcomes.
How much faster was spreadsheet analysis in the 1984 example?
In Steven Levy’s 1984 account, one accountant said a what-if calculation that had taken 20 hours by hand took 15 minutes with a spreadsheet. The example is an individual report, not an average for the profession.
Source: Thorsten Meyer AI
